Trust & safety

Review guidelines

Keyhole works because tenants can trust what they read and landlords can trust they’re treated fairly. These rules apply to every review.

Write about your own tenancy

First-hand experience only, at an address you rented from this landlord. One review per tenancy; you can delete it and write a new one later.

Describe what happened

Dates, repairs, amounts and outcomes. Opinions are welcome when they read as opinions (“felt unfair”), not as accusations stated as fact.

Keep personal information out

No phone numbers, emails, names of staff or neighbors, or anything about a landlord’s private life. Individual owners are listed by name and city only.

No threats, harassment or hate

Criticize conduct, not people’s identity. Reviews that cross the line are removed.

No conflicts of interest

Landlords, their staff, relatives and competitors can’t review. Don’t accept payment, a discount or anything else for a review, positive or negative.

Be fair to the next tenant

Mention what went well too. A balanced review is the most useful kind.

How moderation works

  • Every review is read by a person before it goes live, usually within 24 hours.
  • We never edit what you wrote. A review is either published as written, or not published, and you’re told why.
  • Upload a lease, rent receipt or deposit receipt to earn a Lease verified badge. A person checks it and then it’s deleted; it is never shown publicly.
  • Anyone can report a review. Reports are reviewed within 48 hours.
  • We never remove a review because it’s negative, and landlords can’t pay to change their score or hide reviews.
  • Landlords can claim their profile and respond publicly, once per review. Responses never change a score.

Public records

For some cities we show housing-code violations and registrations published by the city. They come straight from the city’s open data, can lag behind real repairs, and are not the opinion of Keyhole or of any tenant.

Rating categories

  • Responsiveness: how fast they answered messages and calls.
  • Repairs: whether things got fixed, and fixed properly.
  • Deposit handling: fair deductions, returned on time.
  • Rent & fees: reasonable increases, no surprise charges.
  • Privacy & respect: notice before visits, courteous.
  • Move-in condition: clean, safe and as advertised.

Questions or a legal concern about a review? See Content & legal requests.